Criteria | 5 | 4 | 3 | 2 | 1 |
Identification and
Measurement description
| Measurement instrument clearly identified; Provides comprehensive, accurate and succinct description of the measure | Measurement instrument clearly identified; Comprehensive and accurate description of the measurement, however not succinct | Measurement instrument identified; Some description of the measure | Measurement instrument identified; some description of the measure, however, incomplete and/or some inaccuracies | Measurement instrument not clearly identified; Description of the measure incomplete and/or there are inaccuracies in the description |
Discussion of
validity and reliability of the measurement as applied to the
context and target group
|
Provides
detailed and succinct evidence relating to both the validity and
reliability from three or more sources; Validity and reliability
are clearly relevant to the target group and context
|
Provides
detailed evidence relating to both the validity and reliability
from two sources; Validity and reliability are clearly relevant
to the target group and context
| Provides some evidence relating to both the validity and reliability from one source; Validity and reliability are relevant to the target group and context |
Provides inadequate evidence relating to either the validity and reliability and/or no sources used; Validity and reliability relevance to the target group and context is not clearly articulated | Some errors in the reporting of evidence relating to either the validity and reliability and/or no sources used; Validity and reliability relevance to the target group and context is not discussed and/or some errors |
Justification of the selected measure |
Provides
clear, comprehensive and succinct justification of the selected
measure by demonstrating a clear link between the measure, the
context and the target group
|
Provides
clear and comprehensive justification of the selected measure by
demonstrating a link between the measure, the context and the
target group
| Provides adequate justification of the selected measure by demonstrating a link between the measure, the context and the target group | Provides in adequate justification of the selected measure and has difficulty demonstrating a link between the measure, the context and the target group |
Provides weak justification of the selected measure and errors in the linking of the measure, the context and the target group |
Spelling and Grammar |
Writing is clear with few errors demonstrating superior written communication skills. Writing is concise and simple. | Writing is clear with some errors, average written communication skills. Writing is somewhat verbose and overly complicate. | Writing is incoherent, many errors, poor written communication skills. Overly verbose and not clear. | ||
Referencing |
Sources used to substantiate idea, sufficient number of references and correct use of APA format. | Sources used to substantiate the ideas of the report, sufficient number of sources, APA referencing style has been used, however, some errors present APA style guidelines | Sources not used to substantiate the ideas of the report, insufficient number of sources, and/or errors present APA style guidelines |